Stop measuring your brand and start listening

The most useful brand feedback often comes from what customers say and do when nobody is asking them to rate the experience.

Table of Contents

    Spy on Any Website

    Get traffic data and keyword intel on competitors instantly.

    Your brand is built by what customers experience, not what marketing says. That makes understanding — and fixing — the everyday interactions shaping customer perception as important as any campaign, creative, or brand guideline.

    Marketing can influence what customers expect, but the rest of the organization determines whether those expectations are met. A brand promise about simplicity means little when checkout is painful. A promise about customer care falls apart when someone spends an hour waiting for support. And a polished campaign can make the disconnect even more obvious when the experience doesn’t match it.

    Those gaps show up everywhere. Hold times, return policies, website flows, support interactions, employee behavior, and automated responses all contribute to what customers think about a company. If marketing keeps pushing a polished version of the brand while customers experience something else, you’re throwing money out the door advertising a promise the business isn’t keeping.

    Customer perception ultimately belongs to the customer. You can feed it, nurture it, or remind people what you stand for, but you don’t get the final vote. People will experience your company in ways no brand strategy document can anticipate.

    Listen when the customers aren’t performing for you

    Start by changing how you listen. Stop asking for feedback directly. And for the sake of humanity, please stop asking customers how likely they are to recommend your company, product, or service on a scale from one to 10.

    Consumers see that question everywhere, and they’re tired of it. It gives you almost no actionable data about the emotional connection someone feels toward your business.

    10X your SEO with Semrush for Enterprise.

    The world’s most powerful SEO platform, purpose-built for Enterprise.

    Request demo

    Customers also don’t always tell companies what they really think. As Geoff Tuff, Steven Goldbach, and Elizabeth Lascaze write in “Harvard Business Review,” “Businesses can’t improve operations without honest and substantive feedback.” The problem is getting it: Customers can be reluctant to provide candid feedback in the first place.

    That makes the places where customers talk without being asked particularly useful. Reviews on Yelp, Trustpilot, and app stores can expose recurring frustrations. Reddit and niche online communities show how people talk about you when you’re not directing the conversation. Social media behavior — what people comment on, share, or save — adds another view of what gets a reaction.

    There’s also a huge pile of customer feedback already sitting inside most companies. Call center transcripts, support tickets, chat logs, and social comments contain the language customers use to describe what it’s actually like to deal with you.

    AI and natural language processing tools can make that volume manageable. Don’t settle for an overall sentiment score. Look for recurring complaints, changes in how customers describe the company, repeated problems with particular touchpoints, and places where the experience conflicts with what marketing promises.

    Direct feedback can fill gaps when it’s tied to a specific interaction. A brief, single-question survey immediately after checkout or a support conversation will tell you more about that experience than another request to rate the entire company.

    The goal is to hear what customers say when you ask and, more importantly, when they don’t know you’re listening.

    Fix the experience behind the feedback

    Listening is the easy part. If customers repeatedly complain about checkout, support, fulfillment, or an aggressive sales process, that thing needs fixing. Another campaign won’t do any good.

    The fix likely sits well outside marketing. Frontline employees need enough authority to solve common problems rather than simply move customers through a process. Incentives matter, too. If my bank says it cares about customers but rewards employees for turning every service interaction into a sales opportunity, then it doesn’t care about customers.

    Automation creates another opportunity for brand promises to collide with reality. Companies rush to deploy AI chatbots to cut costs and response times, but robotic efficiency isn’t much of a victory when the customer still can’t get an answer. An automated interaction needs to solve the problem while behaving like the company customers were promised.

    And when customer feedback produces a change, tell people. If customers repeatedly complain about a broken checkout process or maddening support policy, and you fix it, say so. Otherwise, the people who complained may never know anyone was listening.

    Keep watching the comments

    Fixing a problem doesn’t settle the question of how customers perceive your brand. Keep watching the comments.

    Reviews, customer service logs, social conversations, behavioral signals, and direct feedback each give you part of the picture. None is the ultimate source of truth, so look across them for recurring patterns and connect those patterns back to specific customer interactions.

    If marketing promises convenience, find where customers keep encountering friction. If it promises expertise, look for the moments when customers can’t get useful answers. If it promises personal service, see whether your automation, policies, and frontline employees deliver it.

    Your true brand isn’t sitting inside your brand guidelines deck. It’s being built every day in checkout flows, support calls, automated conversations, and all those raw customer reactions marketing would probably rather not read.


    Contributing authors are invited to create content for MarTech and are chosen for their expertise and contribution to the martech community. Our contributors work under the oversight of the editorial staff and contributions are checked for quality and relevance to our readers. MarTech is owned by Semrush. Contributor was not asked to make any direct or indirect mentions of Semrush. The opinions they express are their own.

    Mike Ukstins
    Director of Strategic Accounts and Managed Services, Cella by Randstad Digital

    Mike Ukstins, Director of Strategic Accounts and Managed Services with Cella by Randstad Digital, is a creative leader with experience in both agency and corporate settings. He helps companies of varied sizes and industries elevate creative output with a focus on process, people and technology. Mike began his career as a graphic designer, acquiring more than 20 years of experience across the spectrum of creative direction, account service, project management and operations. He has a passion for travel and enjoys spending time with his wife and three energetic daughters.

    View Author Profile